I have a Fractal Design Meshify C and I'm looking to get either the Noctua NH-U12S or the NH-U12A and was wandering what the difference between the two are. noctua nh u12s vs wraith prism, The NH-U14S is the 14cm top model of Noctua’s classic U-series single tower CPU coolers, which have received more than 400 awards and recommendations from the international press. Noctua NH-U12A cooler review Today we are reviewing the newest Noctua cooler, it’s NH-U12A. You get two fans on the U12a vs 1 on the U12s, and the two NF-A12 fans are the newest version vs the older single NF-F12 on the u12S. But even with a permanently positioned case, there were always different test results when the cooler was remounted. I saw that Noctua had white fans come out at Computex, so I would probably replace the brown ones as soon as those came out either way. It’s much more rectangular than its smaller U9S sibling. Only in overclocked mode at very high temperatures the constellation with two fans was superior. 2000 rpm; Airflow. Select part A. Když před pár měsíci uvedli na trh chladič Noctua NH-U12A, okamžitě mě to zaujalo. Making use of the LNA cables reaches about 300 RPM or so of its maximum speed, but it appears t… Relentless81. Compare. The Noctua NH-U12S is not even the best 120mm cooler that Noctua has to offer, that would be the Noctua NH-U12A. AMD Navi: Sapphire Radeon RX 5700 XT Nitro and ASRock Taichi designs emerged, AMD Navi: Overview of all known Custom Designs of the RX 5700 (XT), Rumor: AMD CEO Lisa Su allegedly to join IBM (UPDATE), Boot Kit: AMD sends again a rental set for BIOS update for Ryzen 3000, Nvidia Super: according to Nvidia no RTX 2080 Ti Super planned. 373 posts; 373 posts; Posted May 13. This post is also available in: Deutsch (German). There are now seven U-shaped heatpipes - two more than the previous-generation U12S - and the heatsink fins are soldered to … The fans are all Silent Wings 3 models from be quiet!. As for the installation process, well I think it’s one of the best around. And that’s when the inconsistencies started. In our original tests we only changed the rpm and restarted Prime95, there was no cooling phase. Compare. Noctua NH-U12A £94.99. In this video, I test 8 of the newest 120mm CPU coolers on the market using an AMD Ryzen 5 3600X CPU @ 4.125MHz. For each cooler, 126 minutes of testing were now required, based purely on the test times. Upon opening the box your new Noctua NH-U12S you will be greeted with..yet another box, But this box actually contains all the accessories that you will need to actually mount and well use the cooler, this includes the Intel and AMD mounting hardware, NT-H1 Thermal compound, a screwdriver, extra fans mounts, a case badge, one low noise adapter, 4 black extra rubber fan mounts (Orange if … The Noctua NH-U12A certainly checks each of those boxes, providing formidable thermal performance and a signature look, with a price tag of $100. Hey. A Noctua NH-U12A would knock another 6-7°C off the two fan temp of the NH-U12S. For the test itself we also received a lot of feedback and requests for extended tests – for example with only one NF-A12x25 fan on the heat sink or different speeds. In the new test procedure we then tested the following procedure intensively with the NH-D15: And lo and behold – the test results only varied by 0.5 degrees Celsius. For the upgrade in fan quality and 2 instead of one $40 extra seems like a pretty good deal. The tilting of the case already seems to have caused a change in the liquid metal, which actually affected the temperature. It’s troubleshooting time. With two NF-A12x25 fans, a wider heat sink and an absolute premium price, however, it is only the figurative successor of the NH-U12S, which plays in a completely different class with a narrow heat sink and only one fan. The time required for the new method had now also increased considerably. Therefore, in the new test series, we performed one test per cooler at 100, 75 and 50 percent speed. The Noctua NH-U12S chromax.black is available for an average price of 69 USD or EUR. Discussion. Thanks to the same proven slim-tower heatsink design and NF-F12 PWM fan, it stays true to the NH-U12S’s successful formula of fusing excellent cooling performance with superb quietness of operation and outstanding RAM, case and PCIe compatibility. During this process, the heatspreader is removed, the heat conducting paste is exchanged for liquid metal and the heatspreader is glued on again, resulting in significantly better temperatures. Supporters only /10 Score Supporters only. The heatsink we're looking at today is in their silent series, the Noctua NH-U12S. That said you can slap your own fans on them too, in that case get the cheaper one because the cooler tower is not the same. However, we found some discrepancies in extended tests. Noctua NH-U9S Noctua NH-U12S. We tested a total of seven different constellations: Once again, interesting results were achieved. I was surprised that the NH-U12S with two fans was only slightly worse than the NH-U12A (which has two fans as standard). However, the cooler does not by far need its space and is designed for maximum compatibility with PCIe and RAM slots. One thing, however, seemed particularly strange to us. Conceived to push the envelope of the 120mm form factor, it combines two of Noctua’s flagship model NF-A12x25 PWM 120mm fans with a completely redesigned heatsink featuring 7 heatpipes and an increased fin surface area for superior heat dissipation. The intensive series of tests has also enabled us to significantly improve our testing methodology. Joined: 18 May 2010 Posts: 11,104. Share with friends. or nearly anyone else. The NH-U12S chromax.black is an all-black version of Noctua’s award-winning NH-U12S premium-quality quiet CPU cooler. 2x NF-A12x25 PWM 120mm fan 2. Discussion. 22 dbA; TDP. Share with friends. We do not yet understand why this is the case. Comparison Noctua NH-D15 vs Noctua NH-U12S. Navigation Compare navigation. With the NH-U12A, the Austrian company Noctua has launched a new premium cooler on the market. Share with friends. Our test processor has been delidded and treated with liquid metal for quite some time. It will even fit legacy sockets with a not included, but free adapter kit. Conclusion. The Noctua NH-U12A takes over the heritage of the NH-U12S. For heat generation, we used our Intel Core i7-7700K with the Small FFT test of Prime95. Other options New and used from $41.92. This makes a comparison almost impossible, which is why we finally aborted the test. Noctua NH-U12S TR4-SP3 Closer Look. Noctua designed the NH-U12A to cover a very specific portion of the market – users that want a top-tier air cooler but are limited by the space available in their systems. So I would take the recommendation of AMD to use at least a 280mm AIO to cool the 3950X with a … The Noctua NH-U12A CPU coolers cost is quite premium when compared to performance, but despite the cost the cooler does exactly what it says it does. Speaking of Noctua, the Fuma 2’s size is pretty much the same as the NH-U12A, though it is a bit wider, but that also makes it a lot more compact than the NH-D12. Select part B. And because of the increased copper amount, it generally provides adequate weight to the product while keeping the build quality up to Noctua… New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the pcmasterrace community. Then we would be happy if you also tested Prime95 with only one fan and share the results with us in the comments here! Ascend to... the PC Master Race. I currently have a Ryzen 1600, but plan to upgrade to the 3000 series at some point, and want to know if the U12s will be sufficient in the long run, or if it would be better to splurge on the U12a. Im looking to buy a new CPU cooler because Im not satisfied with the Wraith Prism. The Noctua NH-U12A comes packed inside a premium looking packaging. It isn’t ideal running Prime95 for a prolonged period of time and if you get called away to do something, it could be left running for much longer than needed. Florian Maislinger is author and founder of PC Builder's Club. On the other hand, the best performing Noctua cooler so the NH-D15 chromax.black (will be reviewed soon) is performing 3-5°C better while its surface is much larger. Accordingly, we obtained a test sample from Noctua and installed it in our test system. So is the heat sink significantly different if fans aren’t a consideration? The more than 140 test runs performed were not quite for nothing because of a second thing. For ventilation, we have mounted two 140 mm fans in the front and one 120 mm fan on the rear and set them to 40 percent constantly. NT-H1 thermal compound 6. I'm not talking about the U12S I'm talking about the U12A b00merang69 said: ↑ The D15/D15S will be better as it is a 140mm cooler vs a 120mm cooler and bigger overall as a twin style, not really sure what you are asking as if it fits your case buy the better cooler. Tento chladič nabízí špičkový chladící výkon bez nutnosti gigantických rozměrů dvouvěžových obrů. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Instead of the five heatpipe design of the preceding Noctua NH-U12S, Noctua did the unthinkable and crammed SEVEN heatpipes into the Noctua NH-U12A. The smaller of the two is the deceptively plain-looking NH-U12S, which sports one of Noctua's standard 120mm PWM-driven fans. Okay, so started again with a new test setting. 3700x Noctua NH-u12s vs d15 Chromax. For this section, we’ll just quote from their web site and let the specs & features do the talking. Noctua NH-U9S Noctua NH-U12S. Thanks to the same proven slim-tower heatsink design and NF-F12 PWM fan, it stays true to the NH-U12S’s successful formula of fusing excellent cooling performance with superb quietness of operation and outstanding RAM, case and PCIe compatibility. Let’s dive in and see what this cooler offers. From a quality and performance standpoint, Noctua was able to surprise us again. Coming to that, we have spun this cooler against the likes of Noctua NH-D15, NH-U14S, NH-U12S, and few other 120mm and 140mm air coolers and have some interesting results. So the fan difference is eliminated. The tests from other magazines also spoke against our results. In previous tests without a cooling phase, the temperature still varied by up to 2 degrees Celsius. The first mistakes were quickly found. In any case, the deviation due to the delidded i7-7700K can be excluded as the cooler has not been dismounted and the case has not been moved. I would consult the LTT forums if you don’t get an answer soon, you get what you pay for, from what can tell there is 0 difference between the heatsinks but the fans make all the difference, either way the U14S is still really good, (I use a hyper212 evo and its fine with my Ryzen 5 2600 if this gives you a idea of cooling since noctua would be miles better). level 2. The whole intensive test series around the Noctua NH-U12A brought us at least one insight. 2x Low-Noise Adaptor (L.N.A) 3. Noctua has changed the NH-U12A accordingly in comparison. Parametry a detailyNoctua nepatří mezi výrobce, který by vydával každou chvíli nějaké novinky. - YouTube This new single-tower design is at first glance similar to the NH-U12S; however, it packs two of Noctua's latest fan, the NF-A12x25. Manufacturer: Noctua UK price (as reviewed): £89.95 (inc. VAT) US price (as reviewed): £99.90 (exc. Capodecina. Suddenly it even beat the NH-U14S and NH-D15. Copy link. In today's review we are taking a look at the NH-U12A, a tower CPU air cooler made by Noctua. Compare. When it comes to the noise, the Noctua NH-U12A is audible when both fans are running, but the good thing is that the fans are not loud at all. Now it’s about moving the processor as little as possible. Originally, we tested with a very strong fan curve, which made it much more difficult to compare the individual coolers. Noctua NH-U12S, Premium CPU Cooler with NF-F12 120mm Fan (Brown) 4.8 out of 5 stars 2,689. We took the chance and started our test all over again and made it more detailed. The SE-AM4 version is a dedicated special edition for AMD’s AM4 (Ryzen) platform, featuring the latest SecuFirm2 mounting system for AM4. If this was equipped with the NF-A12x25 fan, it achieved a better result than the first NH-U12A at 75 and 100 percent speed in normal mode. There is no reason for the op to buy a new one. FREE Shipping by Amazon. It has the same large baseplate as other TR4 specific CPU coolers and also works with the AMD EPYC range (SP3 socket). Heureka, the new NH-U12A works better – but the old one too?! In comparison with its brothers NH-U12S, NH-U14S and NH-D15, it is subject to the two 140 mm variants. Curiously, the new NH-U12A performed even better with only one fan than with two. Further adaptations – new system, new test series, Next test – abort in the middle, but the faulty part is found, The Noctua NH-U12A still cools better with a single fan, Conclusion: we need a new test system for CPU coolers, has launched a new premium cooler on the market, Allow to cool down at 100 percent speed for 10 minutes (also at system restart). The Case, a Dark Base 700 from be quiet!, stood upright with closed side panels. So everything indicated that we had a big problem somewhere in our test system. In good faith now to bring a better comparable test, we have again mounted all five test coolers on our mainboard. We only removed the rear fan. This is how we defined our general test method. Welcome to the official subreddit of the PC Master Race. As a skilled IT engineer, he is very familiar with computers and hardware and has been a technology lover since childhood. In preparation for upcoming cooler tests, we have once again revised our test concept. I actually prefer it over anything from Noctua or … AMD Ryzen 5 3400G and Ryzen 3 3200G with specifications leaked, heatspreaders are soldered, Pictures of the AMD Ryzen 7 2700X 50th Anniversary Edition with signature of Lisa Su leaked. But for our cooler tests, that was exactly the problem. Noctua NH-U12A, Premium CPU Cooler with High-Performance Quiet NF-A12x25 PWM Fans (120mm, Brown) Type: Fan & Heatsinks RPM: … Speaking of Noctua, the Fuma 2’s size is pretty much the same as the NH-U12A, though it is a bit wider, but that also makes it a lot more compact than the NH-D12. He is mainly responsible for the news and our social media channels. Other tests also speak against our test, but after this extensive troubleshooting we can almost completely rule out that it is a gross blunder on our part. The test of the NH-U12A turned out a little different than expected. The Noctua NH-U12A is no exception. I know it’s not a completely fair comparison as Noctua’s model is more expensive, while on the other hand, BeQuiet’s model is a dual tower design, but still, it will be interesting to see how they stack up against each other in this Noctua NH-U12A vs Be Quiet Dark Rock Pro 4 face-off.. If you continue to use the website, we will assume your consent. In this video, I test 8 of the newest 120mm CPU coolers on the market using an AMD Ryzen 5 3600X CPU @ 4.125MHz. The main takeaways are – it’s quiet, it claims 100% RAM compatibility (with the inevitable rare-case caveat) and all modern socket compatibility. Noctua NH-U12A performance: ... chance to test almost all of the coolers bearing the name Noctua and so far I was really impressed by only 2 models – Noctua U14s and Noctua U12s. And for that, it offers a good cooling performance with a silent fan, event at the maximum speed of 1500RPM. Left Won; Draw; Left Lost; Number of fans Fan Speed Fan Airflow … Navigation Compare navigation. The second test sample of the NH-U12A performed significantly better than the original sample. Thanks to the same proven slim-tower heatsink design and NF-F12 PWM fan, it stays true to the NH-U12S’s successful formula of fusing excellent cooling performance with superb quietness of operation and outstanding RAM, case and PCIe compatibility. For the upgrade in fan quality and 2 instead of one $40 extra seems like a pretty good deal. Trust. Introduction. Item: NH-U12A. Read More In several tests we have measured differences of up to 3 degrees Celsius. The difference under full load was about 2°C. I know they must be slightly different because the chromax cover works for one and not the other, but not sure if it warrants the upgrade! He claimed that the Prime95 test can vary slightly even in Small FFT mode. Select part B. All these tests have shown us that testing coolers is anything but easy, especially with a delidded processor. And every time there were slightly better temperatures with a single fan. Show info. In today's review, I will be looking at the Noctua NH-U12A. But, what about the performance? From looking at the reviews, it looks like they only differ by 1 or 2 C, and I assume I could just put another fan on the u12s for a push/pull configuration. Noctua NH-U12S Review - Cooling the 3900X with AIR! Its heat pipes have a copper base plate that also has a nickel plating. The Noctua NH-U12A cooled better with one fan than with two in all the tests we did. 95. There are now seven U-shaped heatpipes - two more than the previous-generation U12S - and the heatsink fins are soldered to the heatpipes for superior performance. However, we accepted this for precise tests, above all because the tests work . I actually prefer it over anything from Noctua or be quiet! Press J to jump to the feed. As for the installation process, well I think it’s one of the best around. Is it worth getting the u12a when it comes at a $40 price premium (and doesn’t have chromax covers)? The manufacturer developed the radiator for years and probably tested it even more extensively than we did. Thanks to its completely revised, thoroughly optimised 7 heatpipe layout, 37% more fin surface area (as compared to the NH-U12S) and a dual fan push/pull configuration that uses the new, state-of-the-art NF-A12x25 fans, the NH-U12A pushes the performance envelope in the 120mm class and can actually match or even outperform many 140mm sized coolers. Facebook Site Facebook Group YouTube Channel Twitter, Contact Us Imprint and Legal Notice Privacy Policy. The NH-U12S chromax.black is an all-black version of Noctua’s NH-U12S premium-quality quiet CPU cooler. In our initial test, we measured with some special parameters that make the test result objective, but not always realistic. However at 100% fan speed, the F12 fans ( Come with U12S) actually gives better static pressure with a lower rpm. The first similarity is its total mass. Next to him, I have the Noctua’s NH-U12S, the black Chromax variation of it, which is essentially the same well-known NH-U12S just coated in black, so I figured why not compare these two coolers in a Shadow Rock 3 vs NH-U12S faceoff, since the price difference between the regular NH-U12S and the new Shadow Rock 3 is around 10$, I think this could be a common dilemma among users, … Noctua was also very surprised about the result. Manufacturer: Noctua UK price (as reviewed): £89.95 (inc. VAT) US price (as reviewed): £99.90 (exc. Another interesting result was the NH-U12S. The NH-U12S chromax.black is an all-black version of Noctua’s award-winning NH-U12S premium-quality quiet CPU cooler. The combination was of course also interesting for our tests. They've managed to power past their color choices though and have built a reputation as one of the premier cooling manufacturers on the market today. Copy link ... Noctua NH-U12A. I know it’s not a completely fair comparison as Noctua’s model is more expensive, while on the other hand, BeQuiet’s model is a dual tower design, but still, it will be interesting to see how they stack up against each other in this Noctua NH-U12A vs Be Quiet Dark Rock Pro 4 face-off.. Therefore the factors are sort of compensating each other for U12A vs U12S For me, I have two A12 fans on my U12S before the release of U12A, then I switched to the U12A. Last, but not least, it comes with a solid six year warranty. ... look at the nh-u12a, it has very similar performance to the d15 but much smaller , have it on 3700x and workd very well. Let’s dive in and see what this cooler offers. Therefore, we continued to experiment to find a better test variant. Therefore we are currently planning a Ryzen system with soldered heatspreader. To be on the safe side, from now on we also no longer operated the fans with the mainboard, but with an external fan controller. The Noctua NH-U12S SE-AM4 heatsink uses a single tower design on which we can install up to 2 fans, including a unit of the award – winning Noctua NF-F12 PWM fan. The Noctua NH-U12A is no exception. Your email address will not be published. The fan uses the SSO2 bearing which is Noctua’s own design. Select part A. 3700x Noctua NH-u12s vs d15 Chromax. Get it as soon as Fri, Nov 20. Final thoughts. The new radiator is able to assert itself against the predecessor NH-U12S, but also here the distance is not as good as expected. The cooler comes with a significantly thicker heat sink, which is supposed to offer 37 percent more surface area. Noctua is known for quiet fans and some would say an unorthodox color scheme. Noctua NH-U12A £94.99. Overclocked, the results then gapped clearly apart again, the NH-U12S with the NF-A12x25 fan was even defeated by the original fan. Noctua Metal Case-Badge SecuFirm2™ mounting system for Intel and AMD 5. For future cooler tests, we definitely need a different test system that finally eliminates the deviation from the liquid metal. For High-quality design and build quality The Noctua NH-U12A Equipped with a pair of NF-A12x25 and comes with a total of 7 heatpipes that spans through the fins on the large heatsink, the NH-U12A is already a solid looking single-tower CPU cooler at first glance – except for the color scheme, some people still … With two NF-A12x25 fans, a wider heat sink and an absolute premium price, however, it is only the figurative successor of the NH-U12S, which plays in a completely different class with a narrow heat sink and only one fan. Select part B. Thus, the Fuma 2 is a great value, as it, much like the original, delivers nearly top-tier performance at a mid-range price point. Thanks to the same proven slim-tower heatsink design and NF-F12 PWM fan, it stays true to the NH-U12S’s successful formula of fusing excellent cooling performance with superb quietness of operation and outstanding RAM, case and PCIe compatibility. As soon as our new test system is ready, we will start a new test series. Noctua has a lot to say about their heatsink and of course it’s all good. vs $ 115 $ 93. Noctua claims that the cooler has 37% more fin surface area than their NH-U12S. Then we also know if the strange results were caused by our delidded i7-7700K. 60 cfm; Acoustic noise. 4-pin PWM y-cable 4. The Noctua NH-U12A certainly checks each of those boxes, providing formidable thermal performance and a signature look, with a price tag of $100. The Noctua SecuFirm mounting system coupled with the stright copper base of the cooler, applies the pressure over the CPU surface evenly. The NH-U12S is the latest 12cm model of Noctua’s classic U-series single tower CPU coolers, which have received more than 400 awards and recommendations from the international press. The NH-U12S might not be the best Noctua cooler, but it will cope with a 3900X. In this subreddit, we celebrate and promote the ultimate gaming and working platform. In today's review we are taking a look at the NH-U12A, a tower CPU air cooler made by Noctua. It comes with the following documentations and accessories inside: 1. Copy link. The Noctua NH-U12S TR4-SP3 is the mid-range offering of the line-up and as a result, has a larger overall footprint. It has the same large baseplate as other TR4 specific CPU coolers and also works with the AMD EPYC range (SP3 socket). I think the newer one has higher fin density? In this group test, we'll put nine Noctua fans... Noctua NH-U9, U12S, U14S TR4-SP3 Threadripper cooler review According to sources, Noctua has been confirming that they plan to launch a Chromax.Black version of their (very small, but amazingly potent) NH-U12A cooler. Select part A. The new Noctua NH-U12A was also in our test system. Noctua NH-U12A Chromax.Black. $59.95 $ 59. The Noctua NH-U12A CPU coolers cost is quite premium when compared to performance, but despite the cost the cooler does exactly what it says it does. It was noticeable, however, that the old sample of the NH-U12A performed much better in this test series too and came close to the two 140 mm coolers. You get two fans on the U12a vs 1 on the U12s, and the two NF-A12 fans are the newest version vs the older single NF-F12 on the u12S. Noctua NH-U12S TR4-SP3 Closer Look. The test series with the Noctua coolers was quite suitable for this, as we were looking for faults anyway. 140 W; Consumption. The NH-U12A is the latest, 5th generation of Noctua’s NH-U12 series of 120mm size premium-quality quiet CPU coolers. The Noctua NH-U12S TR4-SP3 is the mid-range offering of the line-up and as a result, has a larger overall footprint.
2020 noctua u12a vs u12s